The Enlightened Investor: A Diversified Portfolio vs. a Collection of Investments “The Only Two Things You Need to Know About Modern Portfolio Theory”

Our best technique for protecting portfolios is called Modern Portfolio Theory. This Nobel Prize winning idea said it is insufficient to look at investments in isolation as is done in the traditional approach of picking stocks and bonds. Rather rational investors will seek out “efficiently diversifi

Table of Contents

Our best technique for protecting portfolios is called Modern Portfolio Theory.

This Nobel Prize winning idea said it is insufficient to look at investments in isolation as is done in the traditional approach of picking stocks and bonds. Rather rational investors will seek out “efficiently diversified portfolios” offering the highest expected return for each level of risk.

In the graph below, portfolios A, B, and C are all efficient portfolios ranging from safer A to riskier C. Portfolio D is an inefficient portfolio. A successful investor would never choose portfolio D because portfolio A has the same expected return, but much less expected risk. Similarly, while portfolio C has the same risk as D, it also has a much higher expected return.

For investors who have accumulated a portfolio of investments, a few investments each year, year after year, how likely is it that they achieve an efficiently diversified portfolio providing the highest return for each level of risk, like portfolios A, B or C? Or is it likely that their “collection of investments” takes too much risk or receives too little return like portfolio D?

Modern Portfolio Theory has two simple objectives for each investor to keep in mind when building their diversified portfolio. The first is that your portfolio must be invested in a manner that captures the full market return of each asset class represented in the portfolio. MPT makes no requirement to outperform the market return, however, you can’t underperform either.

Second, you should choose securities that take market risk (not diversifiable) and eliminate non-market risk, which is diversifiable (as discussed in the previous article Investment Risk).

A simple and modern way to achieve the objectives of MPT in your portfolio is to choose asset class securities called index funds, asset class funds or exchange-traded funds. These are easily combined into efficiently diversified portfolios. Each of these types of securities is designed to earn the market return, protect against underperformance and do so by eliminating unnecessary risk.

If you would like more information or have any questions, feel free to contact us at 780.466.6204, or click here to send us an email.

Thanks to Chris Turnbull of The Index House for providing this article.

The Index House is a division of Polaris Financial Inc.

More Blog Posts

Should Physicians Incorporate? What Still Works and What Doesn’t

Navigating Physician Incorporation: What Still Works and What Doesn’t Physician incorporation remains a complex but often beneficial strategy. Its effectiveness largely depends on how much income you personally require and how much can be left within the corporation. If you can consistently retain e
Learn More
Checklist with red checkmarks and a red marker for task completion.

Integrated Financial and Tax Planning for Yellowknife and Northern Canadian Business Owners

The overall financial health and success of your northern Canadian business ia improved through integrated planning that considers your current circumstances, your long-term goals, and the opportunities that are available to you. With KWB’s Integrated Planning for the Future, you’ll achieve the best
Learn More
Hand stacking wooden blocks with checkmarks, symbolizing organization and task completion.

Most Overlooked Tax Deductions for Canadian Business Owners

This article is an updated version of our earlier post on overlooked deductions. Read the original here. _________________________ Many business owners are missing key deductions that reduce taxable income. Key Deductions You May Be Missing Vehicle Expenses If you use a personal vehicle for business
Learn More
Meditating person in a park, practicing mindfulness outdoors.

Canadian Entrepreneurs’ Incentive: A Tax Strategy for Selling Your Business Shares

For business owners planning a future sale, capital gains tax is often one of the largest costs of an exit. The Canadian Entrepreneurs’ Incentive (CEI) provides a reduced capital gains inclusion rate on qualifying share sales when specific conditions are met. While not every corporation will qualify
Learn More
KWB-Checklist

Optimizing Your QuickBooks Online and Accounting Workflows for Improved Efficiency

Do you and your employees spend a lot of time completing tedious tasks manually? Things like bookkeeping, accounting, and payroll are important, but can be a distraction from the work you really enjoy, and from working ON your business rather than in it. The good news is, these and other internal pr
Learn More
Financial planning with Canadian $50 bills, calculator, glasses, and notebook.

Alberta’s 2026 Budget: What Business Owners Should Know

Alberta has released its 2026 Provincial Budget, outlining major investments in health, education, and workforce development alongside the province’s largest deficit since the pandemic. Here’s what business owners need to know. $9.4B Deficit: No Income Tax Changes for Businesses or Individuals Budge
Learn More